短路额定值:如何计算Type 209电缆地线屏蔽的热短路限制

Short Circuit Rating: How to Calculate the Thermal Short-Circuit Limit for the Earth Screen of a Type 209 Cable
短路额定值:如何计算Type 209电缆地线屏蔽的热短路限制
Understanding the thermal short-circuit current limits of cable earth screens represents a critical aspect of mining cable design and electrical system safety. When a fault occurs in a mining electrical system, massive currents can flow through the cable’s protective earth screen, generating intense heat that must be contained without damaging the cable’s insulation or compromising its structural integrity. For Type 209 mining cables, which serve as flexible feeders to machinery in demanding underground coal mining environments, accurately calculating these thermal limits ensures that the composite earth screen can safely carry fault currents until protective devices clear the fault.
了解电缆地线屏蔽的热短路电流限制是矿用电缆设计和电气系统安全的关键方面。当矿山电气系统发生故障时,巨大的电流可能通过电缆的保护性地线屏蔽流动,产生必须在不损坏电缆绝缘或损害其结构完整性的情况下控制的强热。对于作为苛刻地下煤矿环境中机械柔性馈线的Type 209矿用电缆,准确计算这些热限制确保复合地线屏蔽能够安全承载故障电流,直到保护装置清除故障。
This article provides a comprehensive, step-by-step approach to calculating the thermal short-circuit limits for Type 209 cable earth screens using internationally recognized methodologies. We will explore both the conservative adiabatic calculation method and the more sophisticated non-adiabatic approach outlined in IEC 60949, building your understanding progressively from fundamental principles to practical application. Through detailed explanations of the underlying physics, worked examples with real cable specifications, and practical guidance on applying these calculations to mining cable design, you will gain the knowledge needed to verify that Type 209 cables meet AS/NZS 1802 requirements for short-circuit protection.
本文提供了使用国际公认方法逐步计算Type 209电缆地线屏蔽热短路限制的综合方法。我们将探讨保守的绝热计算方法和IEC 60949中概述的更复杂的非绝热方法,从基本原理到实际应用逐步建立您的理解。通过对基础物理学的详细解释、使用实际电缆规格的实例以及将这些计算应用于矿用电缆设计的实用指导,您将获得验证Type 209电缆满足AS/NZS 1802短路保护要求所需的知识。
Understanding Type 209 Cable Construction and Earth Screen Design
了解Type 209电缆结构和地线屏蔽设计
Type 209 Cable Overview and Applications
Type 209电缆概述和应用
Before diving into short-circuit calculations, it is essential to understand the specific construction characteristics of Type 209 cables that influence their fault current behavior. Type 209 cables are manufactured in accordance with Australian Standard AS/NZS 1802:2018 for underground coal mining applications, with voltage ratings ranging from 1.1/1.1kV up to 11/11kV depending on the specific variant. These cables function primarily as flexible feeders to mining machinery, making them more suitable for trailing applications rather than continuous reeling operations. The smaller conductor sizes within the Type 209 family commonly power handheld equipment such as drills, while larger sizes supply pumps, fans, and other fixed or semi-mobile mining equipment.
在深入研究短路计算之前,必须了解影响其故障电流行为的Type 209电缆的具体结构特征。Type 209电缆按照澳大利亚标准AS/NZS 1802:2018制造,用于地下煤矿应用,电压等级从1.1/1.1kV到11/11kV不等,具体取决于特定变体。这些电缆主要作为矿山机械的柔性馈线,使其更适合拖曳应用而不是连续卷绕操作。Type 209系列中较小的导体尺寸通常为手持设备(如钻机)供电,而较大尺寸则为泵、风扇和其他固定或半移动矿山设备供电。
The typical construction of a Type 209 cable consists of three tinned copper power conductors, each individually insulated with Ethylene Propylene Rubber (EPR) compound rated R-EP-90 for operation up to 90°C continuous temperature. A central extensible pilot core provides mechanical reinforcement and can be used for monitoring purposes when connected appropriately. What distinguishes Type 209 cables from other mining cable types is their composite earth screen construction, which combines tinned annealed copper wire braiding interwoven with polyester yarn to create a flexible yet robust screening system that surrounds each power core.
Type 209电缆的典型结构由三根镀锡铜电力导体组成,每根导体均采用乙丙橡胶(EPR)复合材料单独绝缘,额定为R-EP-90,可在90°C连续温度下运行。中心可延展导引芯提供机械加固,并可在适当连接时用于监控目的。Type 209电缆与其他矿用电缆类型的区别在于其复合地线屏蔽结构,该结构将镀锡退火铜丝编织物与聚酯纱线交织在一起,形成围绕每个电力芯的柔性但坚固的屏蔽系统。
Composite Earth Screen Characteristics
复合地线屏蔽特性
The composite earth screen in Type 209 cables serves multiple critical functions beyond simply providing an earth fault return path. The tinned copper wire component of the braid provides the necessary electrical conductivity to safely carry fault currents back to the source, while the polyester yarn interwoven through the braid adds mechanical strength and prevents the copper wires from being crushed or damaged during the cable’s operational flexing. This hybrid construction represents an engineering compromise between electrical performance and mechanical durability, which is particularly important in mining applications where cables experience repeated bending, crushing forces, and abrasion from surrounding equipment and rock surfaces.
Type 209电缆中的复合地线屏蔽除了简单地提供接地故障返回路径外,还具有多个关键功能。编织物的镀锡铜丝组件提供必要的电导率,以安全地将故障电流带回源头,而通过编织物交织的聚酯纱线增加了机械强度,并防止铜丝在电缆的操作弯曲期间被压碎或损坏。这种混合结构代表了电气性能和机械耐用性之间的工程折衷,这在矿山应用中特别重要,因为电缆经历重复弯曲、来自周围设备和岩石表面的挤压力和磨损。
The electrical cross-sectional area of the composite screen is determined by the total copper content within the braid, excluding the non-conductive polyester yarns. Typical coverage factors for Type 209 earth screens range from 60% to 80%, meaning that 60% to 80% of the screen’s geometric surface area consists of conductive copper wires. When calculating short-circuit ratings, we must account for only the effective copper cross-section, as the polyester component does not conduct electricity and therefore does not contribute to fault current carrying capacity. The individual copper wires within the braid are typically very fine, ranging from 0.3mm to 0.5mm in diameter, which provides excellent flexibility but also influences the heat dissipation characteristics during short-circuit events.
复合屏蔽的电气截面积由编织物内的总铜含量决定,不包括非导电的聚酯纱线。Type 209地线屏蔽的典型覆盖系数范围从60%到80%,意味着屏蔽几何表面积的60%到80%由导电铜丝组成。在计算短路额定值时,我们必须只考虑有效的铜截面,因为聚酯组件不导电,因此不有助于故障电流承载能力。编织物内的单根铜丝通常非常细,直径范围从0.3mm到0.5mm,这提供了极好的柔韧性,但也影响短路事件期间的散热特性。
Fundamental Principles of Short-Circuit Thermal Limits
短路热限制的基本原理
Why Short-Circuit Calculations Matter
为什么短路计算很重要
When an earth fault or short circuit occurs in a mining electrical system, the protective earth screen must carry the full fault current until circuit breakers or other protective devices operate to clear the fault. During this brief period, which typically lasts from 0.1 seconds to 5 seconds depending on protection coordination, the fault current generates intense Joule heating within the earth screen’s copper conductors according to the relationship P = I²R, where power dissipation equals the square of current multiplied by resistance. This heating raises the temperature of the copper wires and surrounding materials rapidly, and if the temperature rise exceeds safe limits, the cable’s insulation system can be permanently damaged.
当矿山电气系统发生接地故障或短路时,保护性地线屏蔽必须承载全部故障电流,直到断路器或其他保护装置操作以清除故障。在这段通常持续0.1秒至5秒的短暂时期内(取决于保护协调),故障电流根据P = I²R的关系在地线屏蔽的铜导体内产生强烈的焦耳加热,其中功率耗散等于电流的平方乘以电阻。这种加热迅速提高铜丝和周围材料的温度,如果温度升高超过安全限制,电缆的绝缘系统可能会永久损坏。
The critical temperature limit for Type 209 cables with EPR insulation is 250°C during short-circuit conditions. This temperature represents the point at which the EPR insulation begins to experience thermal degradation that could compromise its long-term dielectric strength and mechanical properties. However, it is important to understand that this 250°C limit applies specifically to components in contact with the polymer insulation. For the earth screen itself, particularly if it does not make direct intimate contact with the insulation core, higher temperatures up to 350°C may be permissible according to IEC 61443, since metallic screens cool more rapidly than conductors buried within insulation layers. This distinction becomes relevant when applying non-adiabatic calculation methods that account for heat dissipation effects.
具有EPR绝缘的Type 209电缆在短路条件下的临界温度限制为250°C。该温度代表EPR绝缘开始经历可能损害其长期介电强度和机械性能的热降解的点。然而,重要的是要理解,这250°C限制专门适用于与聚合物绝缘接触的组件。对于地线屏蔽本身,特别是如果它不与绝缘芯直接紧密接触,根据IEC 61443,高达350°C的更高温度可能是允许的,因为金属屏蔽比埋在绝缘层内的导体冷却得更快。这种区别在应用考虑散热效应的非绝热计算方法时变得相关。
Adiabatic vs. Non-Adiabatic Heating
绝热与非绝热加热
The term “adiabatic” comes from thermodynamics and describes a process in which no heat is transferred to or from the system. In the context of cable short-circuit calculations, the adiabatic method assumes that during the brief fault duration, all the heat generated by the fault current remains confined within the conductor or earth screen, with no heat loss to the surrounding insulation, sheath, or environment. This simplifying assumption makes calculations straightforward and yields conservative results, meaning the actual temperature rise will be lower than calculated since some heat inevitably does escape.
“绝热”一词来自热力学,描述了一个没有热量传入或传出系统的过程。在电缆短路计算的背景下,绝热方法假设在短暂的故障持续时间内,故障电流产生的所有热量都保持在导体或地线屏蔽内,没有热量损失到周围的绝缘、护套或环境。这种简化假设使计算变得简单,并产生保守的结果,意味着实际温度升高将低于计算值,因为一些热量不可避免地会逃逸。
For fault durations up to approximately 5 seconds, the adiabatic assumption proves reasonably accurate for main power conductors, as the thermal mass of the conductor is small relative to the energy input and the insulation provides significant thermal resistance that limits heat escape. However, for earth screens composed of many small-diameter wires with large surface area relative to their cross-sectional area, heat dissipation becomes more significant even during short faults. This is where the non-adiabatic method outlined in IEC 60949 becomes valuable. By introducing empirical correction factors based on wire diameter, insulation type, and fault duration, the non-adiabatic method can demonstrate that earth screens can safely carry higher fault currents than the adiabatic calculation would suggest, typically 10% to 25% higher depending on the specific construction parameters.
对于持续时间长达约5秒的故障,绝热假设对主电力导体证明相当准确,因为导体的热质量相对于能量输入较小,绝缘提供了显著的热阻,限制了热量逃逸。然而,对于由许多小直径导线组成且表面积相对于其截面积较大的地线屏蔽,即使在短故障期间,散热也变得更加显著。这就是IEC 60949中概述的非绝热方法变得有价值的地方。通过引入基于线径、绝缘类型和故障持续时间的经验校正因子,非绝热方法可以证明地线屏蔽可以安全承载比绝热计算所建议的更高的故障电流,通常根据特定结构参数高10%至25%。
The Adiabatic Calculation Method
绝热计算方法
The Basic Adiabatic Equation
基本绝热方程
The adiabatic calculation method provides the foundation for all short-circuit current calculations and is specified in international standards including IEC 60364-5-54, AS/NZS 3008.1, and BS 7671. The fundamental equation establishes a relationship between the permissible short-circuit current, the cross-sectional area of the conductor, the fault duration, and material-specific constants. Let us build up to this equation step by step to understand where it comes from and what each term represents.
绝热计算方法为所有短路电流计算提供了基础,并在包括IEC 60364-5-54、AS/NZS 3008.1和BS 7671在内的国际标准中规定。基本方程建立了允许短路电流、导体截面积、故障持续时间和材料特定常数之间的关系。让我们逐步建立这个方程,以了解它来自哪里以及每个术语代表什么。
Where | 其中:
I = Short-circuit current in amperes (RMS value) | 短路电流,安培(有效值)
t = Duration of fault in seconds | 故障持续时间,秒
K = Material constant depending on conductor type, initial temperature, and final temperature | 取决于导体类型、初始温度和最终温度的材料常数
S = Cross-sectional area of conductor in mm² | 导体截面积,mm²
The elegance of this equation lies in its simplicity. The term I²t represents the thermal energy input from the fault current, measured in ampere-squared seconds (A²s). This quantity is often called the “let-through energy” or “I-squared-t rating” and represents the total heating effect of the fault. On the right side of the equation, K²S² represents the capacity of the conductor to absorb this thermal energy without exceeding its maximum permissible temperature. By rearranging this equation, we can solve for any unknown variable. For example, if we know the expected fault current and duration, we can calculate the minimum required conductor cross-section, or conversely, given a conductor size, we can determine the maximum permissible fault current.
这个方程的优雅之处在于其简单性。术语I²t代表来自故障电流的热能输入,以安培平方秒(A²s)为单位测量。这个量通常被称为”通过能量”或”I平方t额定值”,代表故障的总加热效应。在方程的右侧,K²S²代表导体吸收这种热能而不超过其最大允许温度的能力。通过重新排列这个方程,我们可以求解任何未知变量。例如,如果我们知道预期的故障电流和持续时间,我们可以计算所需的最小导体截面,或者相反,给定导体尺寸,我们可以确定最大允许故障电流。
Understanding the K Factor
理解K因子
The K factor is the heart of the adiabatic equation and encapsulates all the material-specific thermal properties of the conductor. It depends on three key factors: the conductor material (copper, aluminum, or other), the initial operating temperature before the fault occurs, and the final maximum permissible temperature during the fault. The K factor is calculated from fundamental physical properties including the material’s specific heat capacity, electrical resistivity, and temperature coefficient of resistance.
K因子是绝热方程的核心,封装了导体的所有材料特定热性能。它取决于三个关键因素:导体材料(铜、铝或其他)、故障发生前的初始工作温度以及故障期间的最终最大允许温度。K因子从基本物理性质计算得出,包括材料的比热容、电阻率和电阻温度系数。
Where | 其中:
Qc = Volumetric heat capacity at 20°C (J/K·m³) | 20°C时的体积热容
β = Reciprocal of temperature coefficient (K) | 温度系数的倒数
ρ₂₀ = Electrical resistivity at 20°C (Ω·mm²/m) | 20°C时的电阻率
θi = Initial temperature (°C) | 初始温度
θf = Final temperature (°C) | 最终温度
For practical engineering calculations, IEC 60364-5-54 provides tabulated K values for common conductor materials and temperature ranges, eliminating the need to perform this calculation from first principles. For tinned copper conductors in Type 209 cables with EPR insulation, the relevant values are as follows. Starting from an initial operating temperature of 90°C (the maximum continuous rating for R-EP-90 insulation) and rising to a final temperature of 250°C (the maximum short-circuit temperature for EPR-insulated cables), the K factor for copper is approximately 143. This value applies to the copper wires within the composite earth screen.
对于实际工程计算,IEC 60364-5-54为常见导体材料和温度范围提供了表格化的K值,消除了从第一原理执行此计算的需要。对于具有EPR绝缘的Type 209电缆中的镀锡铜导体,相关值如下。从90°C的初始工作温度(R-EP-90绝缘的最大连续额定值)开始,升至250°C的最终温度(EPR绝缘电缆的最大短路温度),铜的K因子约为143。该值适用于复合地线屏蔽内的铜丝。
| Material 材料 | Initial Temp (θi) 初始温度 | Final Temp (θf) 最终温度 | K Factor K因子 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Copper (Tinned) 铜(镀锡) | 90°C | 250°C | 143 |
| Copper (Tinned) 铜(镀锡) | 90°C | 350°C | 166 |
| Copper (Bare) 铜(裸露) | 90°C | 250°C | 143 |
| Aluminum 铝 | 90°C | 250°C | 94 |
Notice that the K factor increases when we allow a higher final temperature of 350°C rather than 250°C. This higher temperature may be acceptable for earth screens that do not make intimate contact with polymer insulation, as mentioned earlier. Using K = 166 instead of K = 143 in calculations allows approximately 16% higher permissible fault current for the same conductor cross-section, which can be significant in system design optimization.
请注意,当我们允许更高的最终温度350°C而不是250°C时,K因子增加。如前所述,对于不与聚合物绝缘紧密接触的地线屏蔽,这个更高的温度可能是可以接受的。在计算中使用K = 166而不是K = 143,对于相同的导体截面,允许约16%更高的允许故障电流,这在系统设计优化中可能很重要。
Step-by-Step Calculation Procedure for Type 209 Earth Screens
Type 209地线屏蔽的分步计算程序
Gathering Required Information
收集所需信息
Before performing any calculations, we must gather specific information about the Type 209 cable construction and the electrical system protection characteristics. The cable manufacturer’s datasheet provides essential construction details including the total cross-sectional area of the composite earth screen’s copper content. This value accounts only for the actual copper wires within the braid, excluding the polyester reinforcement yarns. For a typical Type 209.1 cable with 25mm² power conductors, the earth screen might contain approximately 30mm² to 35mm² of copper depending on the braid design and coverage factor.
在执行任何计算之前,我们必须收集有关Type 209电缆结构和电气系统保护特性的具体信息。电缆制造商的数据表提供了基本的结构细节,包括复合地线屏蔽铜含量的总截面积。该值仅考虑编织物内的实际铜丝,不包括聚酯增强纱线。对于具有25mm²电力导体的典型Type 209.1电缆,地线屏蔽可能包含约30mm²至35mm²的铜,具体取决于编织设计和覆盖系数。
From the electrical system design, we need two critical parameters: the expected earth fault current at the cable location and the maximum clearing time of the protection devices. The earth fault current depends on the system voltage, transformer impedance, and the impedance of the fault path including the cable itself. In mining installations operating at 1.1kV, earth fault currents can range from a few kiloamperes in well-coordinated systems to over 20kA in systems with large transformer capacity and short cable runs. The clearing time depends on the settings and characteristics of protection relays or circuit breakers, typically ranging from 0.1 seconds for fast-acting electronic protection to 1-3 seconds for slower electromechanical devices or when coordination with backup protection is required.
从电气系统设计中,我们需要两个关键参数:电缆位置的预期接地故障电流和保护装置的最大清除时间。接地故障电流取决于系统电压、变压器阻抗和包括电缆本身在内的故障路径的阻抗。在1.1kV运行的矿山安装中,接地故障电流可以从协调良好的系统中的几千安培到具有大变压器容量和短电缆运行的系统中的超过20kA不等。清除时间取决于保护继电器或断路器的设置和特性,通常从快速电子保护的0.1秒到较慢的机电设备的1-3秒,或者当需要与备用保护协调时。
Worked Example: Type 209.1 Cable with 25mm² Conductors
实例:具有25mm²导体的Type 209.1电缆
Given Data | 给定数据:
• Cable Type: Type 209.1 (1.1kV) with 25mm² power conductors
• Earth Screen Copper Area: Se = 32mm²
• Expected Earth Fault Current: If = 12,000A (12kA)
• Protection Clearing Time: t = 1.0 second
• Initial Temperature: θi = 90°C (continuous operating temperature)
• Final Temperature: θf = 250°C (EPR insulation limit)
• K Factor for Copper: K = 143
We need to verify whether the 32mm² earth screen can safely withstand a 12kA fault for 1.0 second. Using the adiabatic equation I²t = K²S², we can calculate the maximum permissible fault current for the given screen size and compare it to the expected fault current. Let us work through this calculation step by step, clearly showing each mathematical operation so you can follow the logic and apply it to your own cable calculations.
我们需要验证32mm²地线屏蔽是否能够安全承受1.0秒的12kA故障。使用绝热方程I²t = K²S²,我们可以计算给定屏蔽尺寸的最大允许故障电流,并将其与预期故障电流进行比较。让我们逐步完成这个计算,清楚地显示每个数学运算,这样您可以遵循逻辑并将其应用于您自己的电缆计算。
Analysis | 分析:
The calculation shows that with the adiabatic method and assuming a final temperature of 250°C, the 32mm² earth screen can safely carry a maximum of 4,576A for 1.0 second. However, the expected fault current is 12,000A, which is 2.62 times higher than the calculated safe value. This indicates that the earth screen is undersized for the fault level, or that we need to consider alternative approaches.
计算显示,使用绝热方法并假设最终温度为250°C,32mm²地线屏蔽可以在1.0秒内安全承载最大4,576A。然而,预期故障电流为12,000A,比计算的安全值高2.62倍。这表明地线屏蔽对于故障水平而言尺寸不足,或者我们需要考虑替代方法。
At this point, several options exist. We could specify a cable with a larger earth screen, reduce the fault current through system design changes such as current-limiting reactors, improve protection coordination to achieve faster fault clearing times, or apply the non-adiabatic calculation method which may demonstrate adequate capacity. Let us explore what happens if we recalculate using the higher final temperature of 350°C, which may be acceptable if the earth screen does not make direct contact with the insulation cores.
此时,存在几个选项。我们可以指定具有更大地线屏蔽的电缆,通过系统设计更改(如限流电抗器)减少故障电流,改进保护协调以实现更快的故障清除时间,或应用可能证明足够容量的非绝热计算方法。让我们探讨如果我们使用350°C的更高最终温度重新计算会发生什么,如果地线屏蔽不与绝缘芯直接接触,这可能是可以接受的。
Using the higher temperature limit increases the permissible current to 5,312A, an improvement of 16% as expected from the ratio of K factors. However, this is still insufficient for the 12kA fault current. This demonstrates why earth screen sizing is such a critical aspect of mining cable design and why manufacturers carefully engineer the braid construction to provide adequate fault current capacity.
使用更高的温度限制将允许电流增加到5,312A,如从K因子比率预期的那样改进了16%。然而,对于12kA故障电流,这仍然不足。这说明了为什么地线屏蔽尺寸是矿用电缆设计如此关键的方面,以及为什么制造商仔细设计编织结构以提供足够的故障电流容量。
The IEC 60949 Non-Adiabatic Method
IEC 60949非绝热方法
Principles of Non-Adiabatic Calculation
非绝热计算原理
The non-adiabatic calculation method outlined in IEC 60949 acknowledges that during short-circuit events, particularly for components with large surface area relative to their volume such as braided earth screens, significant heat transfer occurs to surrounding materials. This heat dissipation reduces the actual temperature rise compared to the adiabatic prediction, allowing higher fault currents to be safely carried. The method introduces an empirical enhancement factor, often denoted as ε (epsilon), which multiplies the adiabatic current rating to obtain the non-adiabatic rating. The relationship is expressed as I(non-adiabatic) = ε × I(adiabatic).
IEC 60949中概述的非绝热计算方法承认,在短路事件期间,特别是对于相对于其体积具有大表面积的组件(如编织地线屏蔽),发生显著的热传递到周围材料。这种散热减少了与绝热预测相比的实际温度升高,允许安全承载更高的故障电流。该方法引入了一个经验增强因子,通常表示为ε(epsilon),它将绝热电流额定值相乘以获得非绝热额定值。关系表达为I(非绝热)=ε×I(绝热)。
The enhancement factor ε depends on several construction parameters including the diameter of individual wires in the earth screen braid, the type and thickness of insulation in contact with the screen, whether there are filling materials between wires, and the fault duration. For earth screens composed of small-diameter copper wires typical of Type 209 cables, the enhancement can be substantial. Research documented in IEC 60949 and subsequent technical papers has shown that for copper wire diameters of 0.3mm to 0.5mm in EPR-insulated cables, enhancement factors typically range from 1.10 to 1.22 for fault durations of 1.0 second, meaning the non-adiabatic rating can be 10% to 22% higher than the adiabatic rating.
增强因子ε取决于几个结构参数,包括地线屏蔽编织物中单根导线的直径、与屏蔽接触的绝缘的类型和厚度、导线之间是否有填充材料以及故障持续时间。对于由Type 209电缆典型的小直径铜丝组成的地线屏蔽,增强可能是实质性的。IEC 60949和随后的技术论文中记录的研究表明,对于EPR绝缘电缆中0.3mm至0.5mm的铜丝直径,对于1.0秒的故障持续时间,增强因子通常范围从1.10到1.22,意味着非绝热额定值可以比绝热额定值高10%至22%。
Application Considerations and Limitations
应用考虑和限制
While the non-adiabatic method can demonstrate higher permissible fault currents for earth screens, several important considerations must guide its application. First, the method relies on empirical coefficients derived from limited experimental data, primarily from research conducted in the 1980s and 1990s. The accuracy of these coefficients for modern cable constructions with different materials or configurations may vary. Second, the calculation requires detailed knowledge of construction parameters such as exact wire diameter, spacing between wires, and presence of filling compounds, which may not always be precisely known during the design stage.
虽然非绝热方法可以证明地线屏蔽的更高允许故障电流,但必须指导其应用的几个重要考虑因素。首先,该方法依赖于从有限的实验数据得出的经验系数,主要来自1980年代和1990年代进行的研究。这些系数对于具有不同材料或配置的现代电缆结构的准确性可能会有所不同。其次,计算需要详细了解结构参数,如确切的线径、导线之间的间距以及是否存在填充化合物,这些在设计阶段可能并不总是精确知道。
More significantly, the non-adiabatic enhancement depends heavily on factors beyond just the heating effect itself. The actual fault current magnitude in a system is influenced by the aperiodic (DC) component of the fault current, which can increase the thermal heating by 20% to 40% compared to the steady-state AC component alone. Additionally, the protection device clearing time is not simply the relay or breaker operating time but must account for arc extinction time and any intentional time delays for coordination purposes. These factors often have a much larger impact on the required earth screen size than the relatively modest enhancement provided by non-adiabatic calculations.
更重要的是,非绝热增强很大程度上取决于超出加热效应本身的因素。系统中的实际故障电流幅度受故障电流的非周期(DC)分量的影响,与单独的稳态AC分量相比,这可以将热加热增加20%至40%。此外,保护装置清除时间不仅仅是继电器或断路器的操作时间,而必须考虑电弧熄灭时间和任何用于协调目的的故意时间延迟。这些因素通常对所需地线屏蔽尺寸的影响远大于非绝热计算提供的相对适度的增强。
Engineering Recommendation | 工程建议:
For critical mining applications where cable failure could result in significant safety hazards or operational disruptions, it is prudent to use the conservative adiabatic method for earth screen sizing, particularly during initial design stages. The non-adiabatic method can be valuable for optimizing existing designs, demonstrating additional safety margins, or resolving specific technical challenges where the adiabatic calculation yields borderline results. Always verify calculations with cable manufacturers who have specific test data for their products.
对于电缆故障可能导致重大安全危害或运营中断的关键矿山应用,在地线屏蔽尺寸方面使用保守的绝热方法是谨慎的,特别是在初始设计阶段。非绝热方法对于优化现有设计、展示额外的安全裕度或解决绝热计算产生临界结果的特定技术挑战非常有价值。始终与拥有其产品特定测试数据的电缆制造商验证计算。
Practical Design Considerations
实际设计考虑
AS/NZS 1802 Requirements and Testing
AS/NZS 1802要求和测试
The Australian Standard AS/NZS 1802:2018 for underground coal mining cables includes specific requirements for earth screen construction and testing that relate directly to short-circuit performance. The standard mandates that earth screens must provide adequate earth continuity and fault current capacity for the intended application, with maximum DC resistance values specified for different cable types. For Type 209 cables, the standard requires that the composite screen maintain a DC resistance of no more than 5.5 ohms per 100 meters for cables with power conductors up to 35mm², and no more than 3.0 ohms per 100 meters for larger conductor sizes.
澳大利亚标准AS/NZS 1802:2018用于地下煤矿电缆,包括与短路性能直接相关的地线屏蔽结构和测试的具体要求。该标准规定地线屏蔽必须为预期应用提供足够的接地连续性和故障电流容量,并为不同电缆类型规定了最大直流电阻值。对于Type 209电缆,标准要求复合屏蔽在电力导体高达35mm²的电缆上保持每100米不超过5.5欧姆的直流电阻,对于较大的导体尺寸则不超过每100米3.0欧姆。
These DC resistance requirements indirectly ensure minimum earth screen cross-sectional areas, as the resistance is inversely proportional to the conductor area according to the relationship R = ρL/A, where ρ is resistivity, L is length, and A is cross-sectional area. For copper with a resistivity of approximately 0.0178 ohm·mm²/m at 20°C, a maximum resistance of 0.055 ohms per meter implies a minimum cross-sectional area of approximately 32mm² for the earth screen. This provides a baseline verification that the cable construction includes adequate copper content in the earth screen before detailed short-circuit calculations are performed.
这些直流电阻要求间接确保了最小地线屏蔽截面积,因为电阻与导体面积成反比,根据关系R = ρL/A,其中ρ是电阻率,L是长度,A是截面积。对于在20°C时电阻率约为0.0178欧姆·mm²/m的铜,每米最大电阻0.055欧姆意味着地线屏蔽的最小截面积约为32mm²。这提供了基线验证,即在执行详细的短路计算之前,电缆结构在地线屏蔽中包含足够的铜含量。
Coordination with Protection Systems
与保护系统的协调
Effective short-circuit protection for mining cables requires careful coordination between cable thermal limits and protection device characteristics. The protection system must detect and clear earth faults before the cable’s earth screen temperature exceeds its maximum permissible value. This means the I²t withstand capability of the earth screen must exceed the let-through energy of the protection device at the maximum fault current location. Modern numerical protection relays used in mining installations often provide detailed I²t characteristic curves that show the let-through energy for different fault current magnitudes.
矿用电缆的有效短路保护需要电缆热限制和保护装置特性之间的仔细协调。保护系统必须在电缆的地线屏蔽温度超过其最大允许值之前检测并清除接地故障。这意味着地线屏蔽的I²t承受能力必须超过保护装置在最大故障电流位置的通过能量。矿山安装中使用的现代数字保护继电器通常提供详细的I²t特性曲线,显示不同故障电流幅度的通过能量。
When verifying cable short-circuit ratings, engineers should use the maximum prospective fault current at the cable’s connection point, accounting for the minimum system impedance conditions that would produce the highest fault current. The clearing time should include not just the relay operating time but also the breaker interruption time and any intentional delays for selectivity. For example, if a relay operates in 100 milliseconds and the breaker takes an additional 80 milliseconds to interrupt the arc, the total clearing time of 180 milliseconds (0.18 seconds) should be used in calculations rather than just the 100-millisecond relay time.
在验证电缆短路额定值时,工程师应使用电缆连接点的最大预期故障电流,考虑将产生最高故障电流的最小系统阻抗条件。清除时间应包括不仅仅是继电器操作时间,还包括断路器中断时间和任何用于选择性的故意延迟。例如,如果继电器在100毫秒内操作,断路器需要额外的80毫秒来中断电弧,则应在计算中使用180毫秒(0.18秒)的总清除时间,而不仅仅是100毫秒的继电器时间。
Conclusion
结论
Calculating the thermal short-circuit limit for Type 209 cable earth screens requires a systematic approach that combines understanding of cable construction, application of standardized calculation methods, and consideration of system protection characteristics. The adiabatic method provides a conservative and straightforward calculation tool that is appropriate for most mining cable applications, using the fundamental relationship I²t = K²S² with appropriate K factors for copper at specified temperature ranges. For a Type 209 cable with a 32mm² composite earth screen operating at 90°C continuous temperature and limited to 250°C during faults, the permissible short-circuit current for a 1.0-second fault duration is approximately 4,576A using the adiabatic method.
计算Type 209电缆地线屏蔽的热短路限制需要系统的方法,该方法结合了对电缆结构的理解、标准化计算方法的应用以及对系统保护特性的考虑。绝热方法提供了一种保守且简单的计算工具,适用于大多数矿用电缆应用,使用基本关系I²t = K²S²,铜在指定温度范围内具有适当的K因子。对于具有32mm²复合地线屏蔽、在90°C连续温度下运行且在故障期间限制在250°C的Type 209电缆,使用绝热方法,1.0秒故障持续时间的允许短路电流约为4,576A。
The IEC 60949 non-adiabatic method offers the potential for demonstrating higher permissible currents, typically 10% to 22% higher for braided earth screens with small wire diameters, by accounting for heat dissipation to surrounding materials. However, this method requires detailed knowledge of construction parameters and careful application of empirical factors. In practice, successful mining cable installations depend not only on proper short-circuit rating calculations but also on appropriate protection system design, correct cable selection for the application, proper installation practices that avoid mechanical damage to earth screens, and regular testing to verify earth continuity throughout the cable’s service life.
IEC 60949非绝热方法通过考虑向周围材料的散热,为证明更高的允许电流提供了可能性,对于具有小线径的编织地线屏蔽,通常高10%至22%。然而,该方法需要详细了解结构参数并仔细应用经验因子。在实践中,成功的矿用电缆安装不仅取决于适当的短路额定值计算,还取决于适当的保护系统设计、为应用选择正确的电缆、避免对地线屏蔽造成机械损坏的适当安装实践,以及定期测试以验证电缆使用寿命期间的接地连续性。
As mining electrical systems continue to evolve with increasing power demands and more sophisticated protection technologies, the importance of accurate short-circuit rating verification grows correspondingly. Engineers and cable manufacturers working together, combining theoretical calculation methods with practical test data and field experience, ensure that Type 209 cables continue to provide safe and reliable electrical power to underground mining equipment. Anhui Feichun Special Cable Co., Ltd. maintains comprehensive engineering support capabilities to assist mining operations with cable selection, short-circuit rating verification, and system design optimization for the unique challenges of mining applications worldwide.
随着矿山电气系统随着不断增加的功率需求和更复杂的保护技术继续发展,准确的短路额定值验证的重要性相应增长。工程师和电缆制造商共同合作,结合理论计算方法与实际测试数据和现场经验,确保Type 209电缆继续为地下采矿设备提供安全可靠的电力。安徽飞纯特种电缆有限公司保持全面的工程支持能力,协助矿山作业进行电缆选择、短路额定值验证以及针对全球矿山应用独特挑战的系统设计优化。


